Last week, the Utah Education Association (UEA), in concert with a teacher and two parents, filed a lawsuit seeking to block the state’s new school-choice program. The plaintiffs argue that the new Utah Fits All Scholarship program fails to meet constitutional muster in the Beehive State and takes money that would otherwise be used in the public-school system.
Kevin Labresh, a public-school psychologist and a parent, along with parent Terra Cooper and teacher Amy Barton, have joined the UEA as plaintiffs.
Passed last year, HB215 provides up to $8,000 to Utah K-12 students through an education savings account (ESA). Those ESAs can then be used to fund private-school tuition, tutors, educational curriculum, and materials. The legislation creating the program passed overwhelmingly in both houses of the Utah legislature and was signed by Governor Spencer Cox in early 2023.
“Utah already spends less on public school students than nearly every other state,” said UEA President Renée Pinkney.
“The voucher program diverts funds from already underfunded public schools, where 90 percent of our children learn, and places vulnerable students at risk by stripping away protections and accountability,” Pinkney added. “This alarming situation should raise serious concerns about the future of public education in Utah.”
The lawsuit is asking Judge Laura Scott of Utah’s 3rd District Court to declare the new program unconstitutional and bar the state from “implementing, administering and enforcing” it.
Supporters of the program say that it offers parents greater opportunities and offers far more flexibility when it comes to the education of their children. They claim that the union is putting its shared politics before the children.
“It is disappointing that the UEA is putting politics above meeting students’ and teachers’ needs,” said Representative Kirk Cullimor, a Republican, in a statement. “I’m confident in the constitutionality of this program, as it does not take away money from public education and ensures Utah schools continue to receive the same funding per student.”
“Every parent knows that when it comes to education, one size does not fit all. The Utah Fits All Scholarship was designed so every student — regardless of their zip code, wealth, and abilities — has the opportunity to learn in a way that makes sense for them,” said Republican Representative Candice Pierucci, an original sponsor of the law.
“The union’s scarcity mentality, and unwillingness to prioritize Utah children, shows just how out of touch they are with Utah parents and students,” Pierucci added.
Opponents of the program claim it takes money from the public schools, and believe those funds would be better spent improving public education in the state.
“You can’t fund two systems when you already have an underfunded public school system, and public dollars should stay with public schools,” Pinkney noted. “We know kids that attend private schools are doing so because their parents, likely, already have the resources in order to send them to those private schools, and we don’t believe siphoning public dollars for private schools is in the best interest of our public education system.”
One plaintiff, Kevin Labresh, worried especially about funding for his special-needs child. “I worry [about] kids like my son and the other [special needs] students … they’re going to be disproportionately harmed by the voucher program because they don’t have the same protections in private settings that they would have with the public school.”
“The support and the training aren’t always there to help deal with those behaviors and at those specialized issues. So it’s an issue of equity and access.” Labresh added.
Carol Lear, a member of the Utah Board of Education who has also signed on to the lawsuit, claims that her “biggest problem” with the law is that it’s removing funds from the public coffers and that it “strips control from the State Board of Education, which the [Utah] Constitution says should have general control and supervision of public education.”
Opponents of the law believe they are buoyed by Utah’s Constitution, which contains an earmark stating that state’s income tax revenue be used only for public education. In this year’s election, voters will decide whether to remove that earmark with a new amendment. The UEA is fighting tooth and nail against the new amendment.
“If you oppose vouchers, you oppose the constitutional amendment,” Pinkney told reporters.
Lear summed up the teacher’s union position quite well when she said that new law “strips control” from the public schools. It’s not about the kids for the UEA and the other plaintiffs; it’s about control.
Shop For Night Vision | See more…
Shop For Survival Gear | See more…
-
Sale!
Quick Slow Release Paramedic Survival Emergency Tourniquet Buckle
Original price was: $14.99.$7.99Current price is: $7.99. Add to cart -
Sale!
Tactical Camo Nylon Body Armor Hunting Vest With Pouch
Original price was: $49.99.$39.99Current price is: $39.99. Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page -
Sale!
Mesh Shooting Hunting Vest with Multi Pockets
Original price was: $59.99.$39.99Current price is: $39.99. Add to cart
Please Support These Patriotic Sponsors
Solar Power Generator Discounts Along With Free Shipping
- 10% OFF for Jackery Solar Generator 2000 Pro Series with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery SolarSaga 200W Solar Panel with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery Solar Generator 1500 Series with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery Solar Generator 1000 Series with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery Explorer 1500 Portable Power Station with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery Explorer 1000 Pro Portable Power Station with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery Explorer 500 Pro Portable Power Station with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery Explorer 300 Pro Portable Power Station with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery SolarSaga 100W Solar Panel with code "JADEAL"
The University of Georgia is represented by the Georgia Bulldogs . The Bulldogs participate in the Southeastern Conference's (SEC) Eastern Division of the NCAA.
They play their home games in the storied Sanford Stadium in Athens, Georgia. The first season in Georgia was in 1892. In 1942, 1980, and 2021, the Georgia Bulldogs won three national championships.
The Georgia Bulldogs have additionally been crowned the National Champion in four additional seasons by at least one polling organization (1920, 1927, 1946 and 1968).
The Georgia Bulldogs are tied for second place in conference history with their 15 conference titles, including 13 SEC titles, and their 59 bowl appearances, which ranks second all-time.
In addition, the program has produced five top picks in the National Football League (NFL) draft, two Heisman Trophy winners, numerous winners of various national honors, and many others.
Longhorns football represents the University of Texas in Austin often known as Texas, UT or the Texas Longhorns. The Longhorns represent the Big 12 Conference in the NCAA Division. They play in Austin, Texas, at the Darrell K. Royal-Texas Memorial Stadium.
The Texas Longhorns are ranked third and seventh, respectively, in terms of all-time wins and win-loss records, with over 900 victories and an overall win-loss percentage of.705.
The legendary program also boasts four national titles, 32 conference titles, 100 First Team All-Americans, and two Heisman Trophy winners.
Get your Texas Longhorns Revival T-Shirt today. The Texas Longhorns Rustic Revival shirt is also a fan favorite.
Many college sports fans like to wear their gear all around town, get your Texas Longhorns Centered gear and show your support.