Reaction & Commentary
Pushing the limits of my conceptual ability let’s say writing is the deepest form of thinking and sometimes i need to rely on it and so that’s why i’m reading it now the next issue is how i’m going to read it so i’ve written a number of these news pieces let’s say commentaries
Recently and people have objected some people have objected to my tone i’m often dealing with things that i would say frighten me to take on to some degree they’re big issues and they’re contentious and so a handy source of impetus and power i mean motive power in such situations
Is to harness a certain degree of outrage and anger that also fuels my spirit i suppose in some sense when i’m writing these articles it would be easier in many ways just to sit on the couch and and read a stephen king novel but i have to get up the energy
And maybe i do that by relying to an untenable degree on wrath which is a cardinal sin in some regards now it’s not like there’s not things that are worth being irritable about but i thought what i would do today as an experiment is to attempt to read this in the most
Calm and understanding manner that i can despite its rather pointed message and so i’m trying to get the tone right you know and i’m paying attention to the feedback i’m getting from friend and foe alike let’s say and modifying my approach as a consequence and so this is an attempt to
Modify it yet again in the hopes of attaining something better and here we go deloitte is the largest professional service network in the world headquartered in london it is also one of the big four global accounting companies offering audit consulting risk advisory tax and legal services to corporate
Clients with a third of a million professionals operating on those fronts worldwide and as the third largest privately owned company in the us deloitte is a beomoth with numerous and far-reaching tentacles in short it’s an entity we should all know about not least because such enterprises no longer limit themselves to their proper
Bailiwick profit centered business strategizing say but consciously or not have assumed the role as counselors to globalists whose policies have sparked considerable unrest around the world if you’re seeking the cause of the dutch agriculture and fisheries protests the canadian trucker convoy or before that the rise of the so-called
Yellow jackets in france the farmer rebellion in india a few years ago the recent catastrophic collapse of sri lanka or the energy crisis in europe and australia you can instruct yourself by the recent pronouncements from deloitte while not directly responsible they offer an insight into the elite group think
That has triggered these events into the cabell of centralizing globalist utopians operating in the media corporate and government fronts wielding a nightmarish vision of environmental apocalypse outlandish claims in may of this year deloitte released a clarion call to precipitous action trumpeting the climate emergency that currently confronts us
Called the turning point a global summary it is a stellar example of the kind of thinking characteristic of the european union’s bureaucratic overreach that generated brexit a very good decision on the part of the brits in my view and one that is now threatening the very survival of that self-same eu the report
Opens with two claims first that the storms wildfires droughts downpours and floods around the globe in the last 18 months are unique and unprecedented a dubious claim and implicitly that the science is now at a point where we can say without doubt that experts can and must
Model the entire ecology and economy of the planet and that we must modify everyone’s behavior moving forward by hooker by crook to avoid what would otherwise be the most expensive environmental and social catastrophe in history the deloitte models posit that climate impacts could affect global economic output and offer the following figures that
Uncheck climate change will cost us 178 trillion over the next 50 years that’s twenty five thousand dollars per person to put it in human terms who dares deny such facts stated so mathematically so precisely so scientifically let’s update mark twain’s famous dictum there are lies damned lies statistics and computer models
Computer model does not mean data and even data does not mean fact or real world computer model means at best hypotheses posing as mathematical fact no real scientist ever says follow the science yet this is exactly what bodies such as the eu consistently pronounce pushing for collectivist solutions
That often and inevitably do more harm than good solutions in sovereignty what might we rely on instead to guide us forward in these times of accelerating trouble and possibility valid authority rests in the people truly valid structures of authority are local not centralized for reasons of efficiency and emergency
This must not become the generation of yet another top-down tower of babel that will not solve our problems just as similar attempts have failed to solve our problems in the past ask yourself are these deloitte models which are supposed to guide all the important decisions we make about the
Economic security and opportunity of families and the structures of our civil societies accurate enough even to give those who employ them any edge whatsoever say in predicting the performance of a stock portfolio one based on green energy say over the upcoming years the answer is no how do we know
Because if such accurate models existed and were implemented by a company with deloitte’s resources in reach deloitte would soon have all the money that is never going to happen the global economy let alone the environment is simply too complex to model it is for this reason fundamentally that
We have and require a free market system the free market is the best model of the environment we can generate let me repeat that with a codicil not only is the free market the best model of the environment we can generate it is and will remain the best model that can in principle
Ever be generated with its widely distributed computations constituting the totality of the choices of seven billion people it simply cannot be improved upon certainly not by presumptuous power mad globalist utopians who think that hiring someone mysteriously manipulating a few carefully chosen numbers and then reading the summarized output means
Genuine contact with the reality of the future and the generation of knowledge unassailable on both the ethical and the practical front the impact of delusional thinking why is this a problem why should you care well the savior said deloitte admit that there will be a short-term cost to implementing their cure
Which is by the way net zero emissions by 2050 an utterly preposterous and inexcusable goal both practically and conceptually this by the way is a goal identical to that adopted last week by the utterly delusional leaders of australia who additionally committed that resource dependent and productive country to a 40 plus
Decrease by 2005 standards in greenhouse gas emission within the impossible time frame of eight years this will devastate australia as the framers of such plans with their it justifies everything emergency know and even somewhat admit to knowing here is the confession couched in bureaucratic doublespeak from the deloitte consultants during the initial stages
The combined cost of the upfront investments in decarbonization coupled with the already locked in damages of climate change would temporarily lower economic activity compared to the current emissions intensive path the omniscient planners then attempt to justify this with the standard empty threats and promises the suffering is certain the benefits ethereal
Those most exposed to the economic damages of unchecked climate change would also have the most to gain from embracing a low emissions future really tell that to the african and indian populations in the developing world lifted from poverty by coal and natural gas and think really think about this statement
Existing industries would be reconstitute as a series of complex interconnected emissions-free energy systems energy mobility industry manufacturing food and land use and negative emissions that sounds difficult don’t you think to rebuild everything at once and better without breaking everything fixing everything in a few decades in a blindly panicked rush
While demonizing anyone who dares object and what will it take to do so here’s the most alarming part nothing more than quote a coordinated transition that will require governments along with the financial services and technology sectors to catalyze facilitate and accelerate progress foster information flows across systems and align individual incentives with
Collective goals a clearer statement of totalitarian inclination could hardly be penned certain outcomes versus predicted outcomes the one thing the deloitte models guarantee is that if we do what they recommend we will definitely be poorer than we would have been otherwise for an indefinite but hypothetically transitory period yet
Any reduction in economic output however temporary and necessary will be purchased at the cost of the lives of those who are barely making it now period have you all noticed that food has become much more expensive that shelter has become much more expensive that energy is more expensive
That many consumer goods are simply unavailable can you not see that this is going to get worse if the deloitte style moralists have their way how much short-term pain are you going to be required to sustain decades worth all your life and the life of your children it’s very likely
For your own benefit remember that and all this painful privation is not only not going to save the planet it’s going to make it far worse i worked for a u.n subcommittee that helped prepare the 2012 report to the secretary general on sustainable development whether or not it was a good
Idea to contribute to such a thing is a separate issue i do believe at least that the report would have been much more harmful than it was without the input of the canadian contingent we scrubbed away several layers of globalist utopianism and cold war era conceptualization and cynicism that was something
I garnered a key and crucial insight from the several years work devoted to my contribution i learned that the fastest and most certain pathway forward to the future we all want and need peaceful prosperous beautiful is through the economic elevation of the absolutely poor richer people care about the environment
Which is after all all that is outside the primary and fundamental concern of those desperate for their next meal make the poor rich and the planet will improve or at least get out of their way while they try to make themselves rich make the poor poorer and this is the concrete plan remember
And things will get worse perhaps worse beyond imagining observe the chaos in sri lanka if you need proof there are clearly more important priorities than costly and ineffective emergency climate change reductions bjorn lombard’s work among others such as marion toopey and matt ridley has demonstrated that other pressing
Problems could and should take political and economic priority from the perspective of good done per dollar spent money could and should be spent for example to ensure the current health and therefore future productivity and environmental stewardship of currently poor children in developing countries for example how about attending to remediation of
The actual world of pain and deprivation of such children rather than saving the hypothetical world and the hypothetical world of future children in abstraction stirrings of revolt citizens are waking up to this dutch farmers and fishermen are rising up canadian truckers are pushing back and such protests are spreading and
Increasing in intensity as they should why because deloitte consultants and like-minded centralists are pushing things too far it will not produce the results they are hypothetically intending this agenda justified by emergency will instead make everyone poorer particularly those who are already poor this use of emergency force will instead
Make the lives of the working men upon whom we all depend for our daily bread and shelter more difficult and less rewarding finally this use of emergency force will also make the environment worse not better why if you wreak your temporary economic havoc to eventually remediate the world those
Whom you sacrifice so casually in the attempt will descend into chaos in that chaos they will then by necessity turn their attention to matters of immediate survival and in a manner that will stress and harm the complex ecosystems and economies that can only be maintained with the long-term view
That prosperity and nothing else makes possible critics of my view will say we have to accept limits to growth fine accept them personally abandoned your position of planet devouring wealthy privilege join an ascetic order graze with the cattle or if that’s too much and it probably is
Then purchase an electric car if you want one but no diesel-powered emergency backup vehicle or electric power generator for you buy some stock and tesla that’s probably the best bet on that front but you don’t approve of the likes of elon musk do you stop flying
Stop driving for that matter get on your bike instead in your three-piece business suit in the winter if you dare i’ll splash you with icy and salty slush as i drive by in my evil but warm ford bronco suv and help you derive the consequent delicate pleasure of your own narcissistic martyrdom
Save the planet with your own choices but quit demanding that the rest of us blindly follow your dictats quit demonizing and castigating us merely because we don’t just happily cede to you all the extant power we’re not evil just because we don’t believe that you are omniscient we’re not evil
Just because we don’t want you to assume omnipotence and omnipresence too there is simply no pathway forward to the green and equitable utopia that necessitates the further impoverishment of the already poor the compulsion of the working class or the sacrifice of economic security and opportunity on the food energy and housing front
There is simply no pathway forward to the global utopia you hypothetically value that is dependent on force and even if there was what gives you the right to enforce your demands on other sovereign citizens equal in value to you an alternative solution a better way forward would be to
Prioritize the problems that beset all of us on this still green functional and increasingly abundant planet with the requisite focus and attention demanded of a true political class elected by the people capable of and willing to look at everything trying to fix where necessary trying to maintain as much freedom and autonomy as
Possible and stop simply capitalizing narcissistically on the mere appearance of action knowledge and virtue we should obtain true cooperative consent from those affected farmers truckers working-class people who have turned an irritated desperation to figures such as trump and work with them rather than forbidding them with your power or improving them
So they will be finally worthy of your time and attention help replace dirty energy with clean if you must but do it on your own dime and make sure that the results are cheap and plentiful if you want to help the poor and the planet the warning bells are ringing listen to them
Before they turn into sirens we will not advance without resistance through the straits of your enforced privation we will not allow you to steal and destroy the energy that makes our lives bearable and that produces our food and shelter and housing and the sporadic delights of modern life
Just to address your existential terror particularly when it will fail to do so in any case we will not allow our children to be criticized first for having the temerity to merely exist and then deprived of the prosperous and opportunity-rich future we strive so hard to prepare for them
We remain unconvinced that your frightened and self-congratulatory moralizing and intellectual pretension ignorance of the limits of statistics and misuse of arithmetic we do not believe finally and most absolutely that your declared emergency and the panic you sow because of it means that you should now be seated all necessary authority
So leave us alone you centralizers of power you worshipers of gaia you sacrificers of the wealth and property of others you would be planetary saviors you machiavellian pretenders and virtue signalers objecting to power all the while you gathered around you madly leave us alone to prosper or not
As a result of our own choices as a result of our own actions in the exercise of our own requisite and irreducible responsibility leave us alone or reap the whirlwind and watch the terrible destruction of what you purport to save in consequence
