Writer and conservative television and radio personality Mark Steyn has filed an appeal of the controversial decision against him in a defamation case brought by Michael Mann, the creator of the widely discredited “hockey stick” graph that featured so prominently in Al Gore’s fantasy film An Inconvenient Truth.
The DC court, helmed by Judge Alfred Irving, ruled in favor of Mann, awarding the scientist $1 in compensatory damages and $1 million in punitive damages from Steyn. Fellow defendant Rand Simberg was also found to have defamed the climate scientist, but his penalty was far smaller, only $1 in compensatory damages and $1,000 in punitive damages.
In 2021, the entities who published the alleged defamation — the Competitive Enterprise Institute and National Review — were found not liable for any defamation.
Writer Amy K. Mitchell referred to the verdict as “a bad day for America.” She wrote: “The precedent set today … means that disagreement and/or criticism of a matter of public policy — the founding principle of this country — is now in doubt. And should you choose to give voice to any dissent, you can [be] brought before a jury, held responsible, and fined.”
On Friday, Steyn filed a stay of execution of the $1 million award, arguing that “the $1,000,000 punitive damage award is unlawful for numerous reasons”; a motion for judgment as a matter of law (JMOL); and a motion for a new trial, arguing that Mann gave false testimony during the trial, that his lawyers elicited that false testimony, and that those attorneys used “highly improper and prejudicial jury arguments.”
Among other things, Mann’s attorneys compared Steyn and Simberg to Donald Trump and the January 6 rioters, which is especially ironic since one of Mann’s main complaints was that the defendants compared Penn State University’s (Mann’s former employer) investigation of Mann’s hockey stick graph with the university’s hapless investigation of convicted child molester Jerry Sandusky.
While the case was supposedly about defamation, Mann’s attorneys repeatedly brought up climate change and how “these attacks on climate scientists have to stop,” for which the court admonished Mann’s attorneys.
Steyn contends that the actions of Mann’s attorneys argued for a new trial. “Counsel’s highly improper argument that ‘these attacks on climate scientists have to stop’ requires a new trial to avoid a miscarriage of justice.”
In a statement after the verdict, Mann said he hoped it would send a message to those who would criticize climate scientists: “I hope this verdict sends a message that falsely attacking climate scientists is not protected speech.”
But Steyn pointed out in his motion for a new trial that “sending a message” is something that attorneys are forbidden from asking juries to do:
The Court of Appeals “has stated repeatedly that an attorney must not ask a jury to ‘send a message’ to anyone.” Bowman v. United States…. This is the law for good reason: “Juries are not in the message-sending business. Their sole duty is to return a verdict based on the facts before them.”
Steyn’s request for a new trial went on: “Telling the jury ‘these attacks on climate scientists have to stop’ was a forbidden send-a-message argument.”
Also at issue is the astounding $1 million in punitive damages against Steyn, even though the compensatory damage was only assessed at $1. The motion for judgment states:
“Under the law of the District of Columbia, one cannot receive punitive damages if only nominal damages are sought and awarded.” Unidisco, Inc. v. Schattner…. In the District, “‘a verdict assessing punitive damages can be returned only when there is also a verdict assessing compensatory or actual damages.’”
Simberg, who was only dinged $1,001 for his supposed defamation of Mann, also appealed the ludicrous verdict.
“We think this is a very important case for First Amendment freedoms, and even though the verdict was only for $1,001 and we prevailed on half of the statements, the underlying principles in this case merit pursuing an appeal,” said Simberg attorney Mark DeLaquil.
“We’re in a lot of trouble if people can be held liable just because they disagree with a government report,” he added, referencing the inclusion of Mann’s research in a 2001 UN report.
Michael Mann and all climate zealots envision a world where others simply acquiesce to their pronouncements and never ask any questions about how they arrived at their fanciful conclusions of climate disaster. If this ridiculous verdict is allowed to stand, Mann is on his way to getting his wish.
Shop For Night Vision | See more…
Shop For Survival Gear | See more…
Please Support These Patriotic Sponsors
Solar Power Generator Discounts Along With Free Shipping
- 10% OFF for Jackery Solar Generator 2000 Pro Series with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery SolarSaga 200W Solar Panel with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery Solar Generator 1500 Series with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery Solar Generator 1000 Series with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery Explorer 1500 Portable Power Station with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery Explorer 1000 Pro Portable Power Station with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery Explorer 500 Pro Portable Power Station with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery Explorer 300 Pro Portable Power Station with code "JADEAL"
- 10% OFF for Jackery SolarSaga 100W Solar Panel with code "JADEAL"
The University of Georgia is represented by the Georgia Bulldogs . The Bulldogs participate in the Southeastern Conference's (SEC) Eastern Division of the NCAA.
They play their home games in the storied Sanford Stadium in Athens, Georgia. The first season in Georgia was in 1892. In 1942, 1980, and 2021, the Georgia Bulldogs won three national championships.
The Georgia Bulldogs have additionally been crowned the National Champion in four additional seasons by at least one polling organization (1920, 1927, 1946 and 1968).
The Georgia Bulldogs are tied for second place in conference history with their 15 conference titles, including 13 SEC titles, and their 59 bowl appearances, which ranks second all-time.
In addition, the program has produced five top picks in the National Football League (NFL) draft, two Heisman Trophy winners, numerous winners of various national honors, and many others.
Longhorns football represents the University of Texas in Austin often known as Texas, UT or the Texas Longhorns. The Longhorns represent the Big 12 Conference in the NCAA Division. They play in Austin, Texas, at the Darrell K. Royal-Texas Memorial Stadium.
The Texas Longhorns are ranked third and seventh, respectively, in terms of all-time wins and win-loss records, with over 900 victories and an overall win-loss percentage of.705.
The legendary program also boasts four national titles, 32 conference titles, 100 First Team All-Americans, and two Heisman Trophy winners.
Get your Texas Longhorns Revival T-Shirt today. The Texas Longhorns Rustic Revival shirt is also a fan favorite.
Many college sports fans like to wear their gear all around town, get your Texas Longhorns Centered gear and show your support.